12 Red Flags To Look For During An Interview
Signs You Shouldn't Hire Someone
One of the most powerful ways to protect your company's culture is through the interview process. As the interviewer, you are the gatekeeper—the person who decides what (and who) is allowed into your organization. This is a unique opportunity where you hold all the control to safeguard your team from potential problems down the road.
To make the most of this critical responsibility, it’s essential to be on the lookout for red flags during the interview process. These are the warning signs that could signal issues later on, and identifying them early can save your organization from headaches, drama, and turnover. Here’s a detailed breakdown of what to watch for and why it matters.
1. No-Shows and Poor Communication
If a candidate doesn’t show up for an interview without notice, it’s an immediate red flag. Life happens, but in today’s world of instant communication, there’s no excuse for failing to send a quick message. Excuses like “my car was in the shop,” “I was stuck in traffic,” or “my internet went down” are only acceptable if the candidate notified you in advance—ideally at least 24 hours, but even a two-hour notice shows respect. If you’re left sitting in the interview waiting for someone who never shows up, imagine how that lack of consideration will translate into the workplace.
2. Ignoring Calendar Invites
When scheduling interviews, most companies send calendar invites to confirm details. Pay attention to whether the candidate accepts the invite. This small action does more than confirm their attendance—it reveals their comfort level with basic organizational tools and technology. If they don’t accept the invite, it may indicate that they don’t use online calendars or aren’t detail-oriented. This could lead to problems if your workplace requires technology for scheduling, time management, or communication.
3. Delayed Responses to Requests
During the interview process, you might ask candidates for documents like references, a driver’s license, or responses to aptitude tests. Their timeliness in providing these items is critical. If they’re slow to respond—or worse, fail to provide the requested information—it’s a sign they may lack follow-through or a sense of urgency. Remember, if they can’t meet deadlines now, when they’re eager to make a good impression, it’s unlikely they’ll improve once they’re hired.
4. Overemphasis on Pay and Benefits
While it’s normal for candidates to inquire about salary and benefits, an obsession with these topics is a warning sign. If they repeatedly steer the conversation toward compensation, it indicates their primary motivation is financial. This mindset can lead to high turnover, as these individuals are likely to leave the moment they find a better-paying opportunity. Instead, prioritize candidates who express excitement about the work, the mission, or the culture.
5. Blaming Others for Past Challenges
When candidates discuss their previous jobs, pay close attention to how they frame their experiences. Do they acknowledge their role in challenges, or do they blame former managers, coworkers, or company policies for every problem? Candidates who lack accountability often bring negativity into a new workplace. On the other hand, those who own their mistakes and show a willingness to grow are far more likely to contribute positively.
6. Excessive Drama or Personal Excuses
Candidates who bring up a string of personal dramas—like ongoing family issues, health problems, or logistical excuses—may have difficulty setting boundaries. This lack of stability can spill over into the workplace, causing disruptions and lowering morale. While it’s important to be empathetic, frequent drama can indicate poor time management, ineffective communication, and an inability to separate personal life from professional responsibilities.
7. Lack of Strong Personal Relationships
A candidate’s ability to maintain healthy relationships outside of work often reflects their ability to collaborate and build trust within a team. Ask about their social circle—whether they have close friends or strong family connections. If a candidate struggles to maintain relationships, it’s likely they’ll face similar challenges at work, leading to conflicts or disengagement.
8. Vague, Canned Responses
Be wary of candidates who give overly polished or generic answers to interview questions. For example, if you ask about a time they solved a problem and they provide a vague response with no specific details, it could mean they’re either hiding something or lack real experience. Look for candidates who can provide clear examples and demonstrate authenticity. This will give you a better sense of their true capabilities and personality.
9. Misaligned Priorities Between Work and Hobbies
While hobbies are important for a well-rounded life, be cautious of candidates who appear more committed to their personal interests than their professional goals. For example, if they talk at length about fishing, crafting, or sports but show little enthusiasm for career development, it might indicate they view the job as merely a paycheck. Look for a balance—people who value both personal fulfillment and professional growth.
10. Overemphasis on Promotions or Titles
Candidates who focus on climbing the corporate ladder may be driven more by status than by meaningful contributions. If they express frustration about not being promoted at a previous job, dig deeper. Were they overlooked because they lacked the necessary skills or leadership qualities? Those seeking promotions for the wrong reasons—like recognition or ego—may struggle to fit into a team-oriented culture.
11. Lack of Responsibility for Past Failures
When discussing past jobs, some candidates may describe bad experiences with former employers or colleagues. While this can be valid, listen carefully to how they frame these stories. Do they acknowledge their own role in the situation? For example, a candidate who says, “My manager didn’t communicate expectations clearly” without adding, “and I should have asked more questions” may lack self-awareness. Candidates who take responsibility for their actions are more likely to grow and succeed in your organization.
12. A Tendency Toward Workplace Drama
Candidates who frequently mention disputes with managers, coworkers, or clients should raise a red flag. Even if they downplay their involvement, repeated mentions of conflict suggest they may bring similar issues to your organization. Pay attention to how they describe these situations—do they focus on resolving the conflict or simply placing blame?
Final Thoughts: Why It Matters
The interview process is your best opportunity to learn about a candidate before they join your team. By paying close attention to these red flags, you can avoid bringing in individuals who may disrupt your culture, create conflict, or fail to meet expectations. Trust your instincts, ask probing questions, and prioritize candidates who align with your values.
Subscribe
Get weekly no-nonsense, thought-provoking articles on leadership & culture that inspire action.